When US streaming giant Netflix launched in Germany, Austria, Switzerland, France, Belgium and Luxemburg in 2014, it heavily relied on its catalogue of standard American fare. But then came supernatural German hit thriller DARK in 2017 –Netflix’ first very successful foray into milking the global content creation market—and they haven’t stopped maximising this business model since, with crime show DOGS OF BERLIN (2018) or the popular coming-of-age dramedy HOW TO SELL DRUGS ONLINE – FAST (2019). With their latest German production, the teen drama WE ARE THE WAVE that just started airing, Netflix is going daringly political.Monday, January 6. 2020
“We Are the (Next) Wave”: New Netflix series goes from anti-fascist original to left-wing guerrillas
When US streaming giant Netflix launched in Germany, Austria, Switzerland, France, Belgium and Luxemburg in 2014, it heavily relied on its catalogue of standard American fare. But then came supernatural German hit thriller DARK in 2017 –Netflix’ first very successful foray into milking the global content creation market—and they haven’t stopped maximising this business model since, with crime show DOGS OF BERLIN (2018) or the popular coming-of-age dramedy HOW TO SELL DRUGS ONLINE – FAST (2019). With their latest German production, the teen drama WE ARE THE WAVE that just started airing, Netflix is going daringly political.A group of teenagers dream of a better future. Their leader, a newcomer at school, recruits four friends to start a youth movement. But their ideas develop a dangerous momentum. The series is loosely based on the young adult novel “The Wave” by Morton Rhue, a story about an American history teacher who tries to explain to his high school students through a social experiment how a fascist regime evolves. In 2008, a German film of the same name was released, starring Jürgen Vogel (THE FREE WILL) eerily directed by Dennis Gansel, who would go off to Hollywood to do THE MECHANIC: RESURRECTION. With WE ARE THE WAVE, Gansel (BEFORE THE FALL; WE ARE THE NIGHT) is back as executive producer.
Same topic, different angle: Instead of students turning fascist, we meet a group of increasingly radicalized left-wing guerrillas – a provocative and risky decision in 2019 that sparked fierce debates on social media right after the teaser trailer was released. No wonder, considering Germany’s past and the fact that “mainstream” fascist movements as well as right-wing terrorist attacks are on the increase. During the 2017 federal election, the far-right party AfD (Alternative for Germany) took more than 12% of the vote and is now represented in all provincial parliaments. In the most recent provincial election, in the south-eastern state of Thuringia, the AfD came in second with 22%, barely 2% behind Merkel’s ruling conservatives and well before all other traditional democratic parties. THE WAVE in real life.
Thus German weekly Zeit complained about bad timing for the new Netflix show: “There are enough arguments for telling a story about the radicalization of youth to the right. The producers and writers of WE ARE THE WAVE even picked the right book template.” Director Anca Miruna Lăzărescu countered: “Which topics are relevant today? Why are young people out on the streets protesting? Our ‘Wave’ focusses on the current youth movement, driven by idealism and a desire for change.” Co-director Mark Monheim added: ‘Wave’ is young, exciting, fast. For us it was important to combine hyper-current discourse with exciting entertainment in this series format.“
In several interviews creator Gansel explained that he didn’t want to use the same narrative again but wanted to move the conversation a decade ahead from the last adaptation and into our future. Currently, we see people of all ages on the street, demonstrating for equal rights or the protection of the environment (Fridays for Future, Extinction Rebellion, the MeToo movement etc.), but not much seems to change in the political arena. Sensing a social context of dissent, protest, and the questioning of existing values, Gansel proposed his core questions: “Which world do we want to live in? And what will happen if the generation in power will not affect change?” One reaction to the show’s setting was that it was criticised as a piece of propaganda aimed against the anti-fascist movement. Let’s have a look at the show then:
The first episode of WE ARE THE WAVE starts with the arrival of a new mysterious high school student named Tristan (Ludwig Simon, one of a whole cast of fresh faces) in a fictional German city. He is good-looking, intelligent, plays the piano and casually speaks fluent Arabic. Too good to be true? With this kind of charisma, he makes friends in no time: Lea is rich but feels lost and unhappy; Zazie is being bullied by her classmates; Rahim is a victim of racism; and Hagen lost everything after the family farm was destroyed by waste from a paper mill. What unites these teenagers is their outsider status in a society that seems to be full of injustices. Together, they start to take action and organise protest campaigns against sexism, environmental pollution, capitalism and racism. Contrary to what other critics feared, anti-fascism and left-wing extremism aren’t glorified either. The activists are merely depicted as a young and unexperienced group of teenagers who act in the heat of the moment without planning their political initiatives all the way through. Hence, the situation quickly gets out of hand. It isn’t until somebody actually gets hurt that the teenagers start reflecting on their actions. Eventually, everyone has to decide for themselves how far they would go for their ideals and whether the end justifies the means – including the viewers.
While the concept of WE ARE THE WAVE sounds intriguing, the end result is not as convincing as it could have been and deflates the initial left-right controversy. The first season has six episodes, so complex social issues like sexism are only touched upon. Focussing on one social issue per episode could have gotten us deeper. The same goes for the narration. The characters develop so abruptly that the story loses authenticity. It girl Lea, for instance, goes from wearing designer clothes to giving up her privileges to fight for the environment overnight. Most importantly, a political analysis of the mechanisms and development of extremist movements –as delivered in detail in the novel and the film– is missing in the series. The story doesn't get more transparent towards the end, on the contrary, it raises further questions – perhaps to tease a second season?
by Dilan Yildirim & Jutta Brendemühl
image: Netflix promo image
Same topic, different angle: Instead of students turning fascist, we meet a group of increasingly radicalized left-wing guerrillas – a provocative and risky decision in 2019 that sparked fierce debates on social media right after the teaser trailer was released. No wonder, considering Germany’s past and the fact that “mainstream” fascist movements as well as right-wing terrorist attacks are on the increase. During the 2017 federal election, the far-right party AfD (Alternative for Germany) took more than 12% of the vote and is now represented in all provincial parliaments. In the most recent provincial election, in the south-eastern state of Thuringia, the AfD came in second with 22%, barely 2% behind Merkel’s ruling conservatives and well before all other traditional democratic parties. THE WAVE in real life.
Thus German weekly Zeit complained about bad timing for the new Netflix show: “There are enough arguments for telling a story about the radicalization of youth to the right. The producers and writers of WE ARE THE WAVE even picked the right book template.” Director Anca Miruna Lăzărescu countered: “Which topics are relevant today? Why are young people out on the streets protesting? Our ‘Wave’ focusses on the current youth movement, driven by idealism and a desire for change.” Co-director Mark Monheim added: ‘Wave’ is young, exciting, fast. For us it was important to combine hyper-current discourse with exciting entertainment in this series format.“
In several interviews creator Gansel explained that he didn’t want to use the same narrative again but wanted to move the conversation a decade ahead from the last adaptation and into our future. Currently, we see people of all ages on the street, demonstrating for equal rights or the protection of the environment (Fridays for Future, Extinction Rebellion, the MeToo movement etc.), but not much seems to change in the political arena. Sensing a social context of dissent, protest, and the questioning of existing values, Gansel proposed his core questions: “Which world do we want to live in? And what will happen if the generation in power will not affect change?” One reaction to the show’s setting was that it was criticised as a piece of propaganda aimed against the anti-fascist movement. Let’s have a look at the show then:
The first episode of WE ARE THE WAVE starts with the arrival of a new mysterious high school student named Tristan (Ludwig Simon, one of a whole cast of fresh faces) in a fictional German city. He is good-looking, intelligent, plays the piano and casually speaks fluent Arabic. Too good to be true? With this kind of charisma, he makes friends in no time: Lea is rich but feels lost and unhappy; Zazie is being bullied by her classmates; Rahim is a victim of racism; and Hagen lost everything after the family farm was destroyed by waste from a paper mill. What unites these teenagers is their outsider status in a society that seems to be full of injustices. Together, they start to take action and organise protest campaigns against sexism, environmental pollution, capitalism and racism. Contrary to what other critics feared, anti-fascism and left-wing extremism aren’t glorified either. The activists are merely depicted as a young and unexperienced group of teenagers who act in the heat of the moment without planning their political initiatives all the way through. Hence, the situation quickly gets out of hand. It isn’t until somebody actually gets hurt that the teenagers start reflecting on their actions. Eventually, everyone has to decide for themselves how far they would go for their ideals and whether the end justifies the means – including the viewers.
While the concept of WE ARE THE WAVE sounds intriguing, the end result is not as convincing as it could have been and deflates the initial left-right controversy. The first season has six episodes, so complex social issues like sexism are only touched upon. Focussing on one social issue per episode could have gotten us deeper. The same goes for the narration. The characters develop so abruptly that the story loses authenticity. It girl Lea, for instance, goes from wearing designer clothes to giving up her privileges to fight for the environment overnight. Most importantly, a political analysis of the mechanisms and development of extremist movements –as delivered in detail in the novel and the film– is missing in the series. The story doesn't get more transparent towards the end, on the contrary, it raises further questions – perhaps to tease a second season?
by Dilan Yildirim & Jutta Brendemühl
image: Netflix promo image
Trackbacks
Trackback specific URI for this entry
